Before and After in Lidar: Rensselaer and Dunkirk, New York
Where the ground dropped and where it rose between two USGS lidar surveys, measured by subtracting one from the other. Two places in New York, each one link away on the map.
USGS publishes a 3.3 ft lidar DEM from many of the lidar surveys it holds, all on the same grid, so two surveys of the same ground line up cell for cell. Subtract the older one from the newer one and what is left is change. In New York that is possible where the ground has been flown more than once: In New York, USGS publishes lidar DEMs from more than one survey of the same ground around Albany (flown 2015–2016 and 2019–2020), on Long Island (2014 and 2024), at Oswego (2014–2015, 2018 and 2023) and at Dunkirk (2014 and 2017). Most of the state has one such survey or none yet. The site takes each survey’s years from its collection dates, not its name.
On the change map, red is ground that went down and blue is ground that came up, and differences under ±1 ft are left clear as survey noise. The figures below are for a box around each place, its size given with each one, computed with the same code the map runs.
Rensselaer: an excavation turned into a mound
East of downtown, city of Rensselaer, Rensselaer County, across the Hudson from Albany · box about 0.83 mi across, 440 acres compared
Before: NY_ColumbiaRensselaer_2016_C18, collected December 2015 to March 2016. After: NY_FEMAR2_Central_2018_D19, collected April 2019 to September 2020. Photos: 2014, 2017 and 2021.
Swipe the photos and the site changes character. In 2014 and 2017 it is a working excavation: cut faces and stockpiles in its northern half, bare graded ground in the south. By 2021 the whole site is one shaped mound, with benches and access roads around it.
The change map shows both halves of that. The ground rose over 58 acres, by 3,601,205 cu yd in all and by up to 160 ft in places. It dropped by 1,767,911 cu yd over 20 acres, the deepest by 169 ft. The southern half of the site almost only rose; nearly all the lowered ground is in the northern half, where the excavation was cut deeper in places and built up in others. Steep cut faces are where two surveys disagree most, so treat the single deepest and highest figures with caution and the broad patches with confidence. The streets and houses around the site read almost entirely clear.
- Ground lowered: 1,767,911 cu yd over 20 acres, the deepest by 169 ft
- Ground raised: 3,601,205 cu yd over 58 acres, the highest by 160 ft
- Median change across the box: 0.2 ft
On the map, choose Compare this view, then pick these two surveys and Compare surveys. Before & after photos then swipes between two years of aerial photos.
Dunkirk: a stockpile on the Lake Erie shore taken down
On the Lake Erie shore, city of Dunkirk, Chautauqua County · box about 0.28 mi across, 49 acres compared
Before: FEMA_Region_2_NY_Great_Lakes_Area_QL2_LiDAR (NY_FEMA_R2L1_ChautauquaCo_2014), collected May 2014. After: NY_SouthwestNY_2017_A17 (NY_Southwest_East_2017), collected April to May 2017. Photos: 2012, 2016 and 2019.
Beside the plant on the shore is a walled stockyard. In the 2012 photo it holds a large, dark, mounded stockpile; in the 2016 photo the same yard holds only a thin, flattened spread with bare patches, and in the 2019 photo it is still low, with plants growing over it. The change map says how much lower the ground there is; it cannot say what the material was.
Almost all the change in the box is that yard: 61,207 cu yd gone from 5.2 acres, by up to 25 ft. Raised ground is slight, 768 cu yd over 0.24 acre, and the highest rise in the box is a reading on the lake, not ground. About two fifths of the box is Lake Erie, which both surveys give a level surface: the 2017 survey reads it 0.6 ft lower than the 2014 one. That step in the water level, under the noise threshold, is why the median across the box is -0.6 ft; over the land alone it rounds to 0.0 ft.
- Ground lowered: 61,207 cu yd over 5.2 acres, the deepest by 25 ft
- Ground raised: 768 cu yd over 0.24 acre, the highest by 8 ft, a reading on the lake, not ground
- Median change across the box: -0.6 ft, the lake surface, not the ground (see above); over the land, 0.0 ft
On the map, choose Compare this view, then pick these two surveys and Compare surveys. Before & after photos then swipes between two years of aerial photos.
Compare two surveys anywhere they overlap
Frame an area up to 1.24 mi across, or select a parcel, and compare. Free to use, no account.
Open Elevation Change →How to read a change map
- Built-up ground, such as a pad, a fill or a mound, shows as a patch of blue; ground cut down or a stockpile removed shows as red.
- A working excavation shows both colors close together, red where material was dug out and blue where ground was built back up.
- A whole area one color can be real, or an offset between the two surveys. The panel says by how much, and names the geoid models when the surveys used different ones, as both pairs here do.
- A block that follows a structure’s outline is worth checking against the photos. In downtown Albany the Empire State Plaza reads tens of feet lower in the later survey, as one even block: the two surveys treated the raised plaza differently, which is not a change in the ground.
- Speckle under dense trees, on water and on steep faces is mostly noise. On the Great Lakes shore the lake level differs between surveys, so leave open water out of an area where you can. Trust broad, consistent patches.
Take it further
The change downloads as a GeoTIFF for GIS with a pass. The photos are on the map only.
Related guides
- Lidar coverage in New York — which lidar project covers an address, and when it was flown.
- Lidar data for New York — USGS 3DEP lidar across the state.
- Terrain checks before buying rural land — including signs of past earthwork.
Frequently asked questions
Can I do this for my own property?
Where USGS publishes a 3.3 ft lidar DEM from two surveys of the same ground, yes. In New York, USGS publishes lidar DEMs from more than one survey of the same ground around Albany (flown 2015–2016 and 2019–2020), on Long Island (2014 and 2024), at Oswego (2014–2015, 2018 and 2023) and at Dunkirk (2014 and 2017). Most of the state has one such survey or none yet. Open Elevation Change, frame an area up to 1.24 mi across or select a parcel, and the panel lists the surveys that cover it. Data Here shows which surveys cover a spot.
How much can I trust the numbers?
Changes smaller than ±1 ft are treated as survey noise and left out. The median change over the land was 0.2 ft at Rensselaer and 0.0 ft at Dunkirk, so the surveys agree closely on ground that did not move, even though each pair was processed with different geoid models. The volumes are good for scale and comparison: indicative only, not a survey.
Why does a new building not show?
The comparison uses bare-earth lidar, which has buildings and trees removed. New buildings and cleared trees mostly don’t show; the earthworks under them do.
Will I get exactly these figures?
Only for exactly these boxes and these two surveys. The links open the map on each spot; the area you frame or draw there will differ a little, and so will the totals. At Rensselaer the panel also offers a third survey, flown 2022 to 2023.
Can I download the change?
Comparing on the map and the before-and-after photos are free. The change itself downloads as a GeoTIFF, which needs a pass. The photos are for viewing on the map only.
About the data
Ground elevations come from the public-domain USGS 3DEP seamless bare-earth model, above NAVD 88. Source detail varies by location. Lidar coverage and source resolution vary across New York. Check your location against the USGS 3DEP index; no statewide coverage percentage is asserted. Buildings and trees are excluded from every terrain analysis in this edition. The comparisons read each survey’s own USGS 3.3 ft lidar DEM straight from the USGS files, not the seamless model the other tools use. More from the USGS 3D Elevation Program.